Dan Silkstone in the Sunday Age, 25th April 2010:
Dees lapping up sweet taste of victory
Not so long ago some wondered if Dean Bailey had a gameplan. Any blueprint, imperfectly implemented, will look haphazard. But when the targets are hit, the ball skilfully shared and the opposition virtually surrendering, the plan becomes obvious and obviously effective. There was more than a little Geelong about the way they ran in packs, drew the tackle and dished the handball. It was a game won in transition and the transition was lightning quick. The goals and honours were well shared out. Davey, Sylvia, Petterd and Trengove all bagged two. All were excellent.
Rohan Connolly in the Monday Age, 26th April 2010:
Copy cats
Much of the football world will blanch at any comparison of the Demons with the peerless Geelong, but you simply cannot escape the similarities in both how Melbourne plays and the assortment of personnel it is assembling to do so.
[Melbourne] is clearly, and rightly, using the Cats as prototype for its own model.
The mere suggestion of that seemed laughable after the Hawthorn debacle. But some gritting of teeth from the senior heads in the Demon line-up and the spark of youngsters like Scully, Trengove and Grimes is giving Melbourne an infectious energy. And so rapidly is the momentum gathering that who is to doubt just how far it could lead?
Tony T. in the AGB, 31 March 2008:
Rot Socks
[Melbourne's] game plan looks roughly similar to Geelong 2007: have most (give or take full back and full forward) of your players move up and down the ground bunched within a kick of where the ball is at any one time. This means you always have loads of players around the ball who can a) put maximum pressure on the other side when they have the ball; and b) "run and carry" the agate down the ground en masse when you get your hands on the ball. It's what Geelong do perfectly. Melbourne's not insignificant problem is that we don't have Geelong's players. No Ablett, Bartell, Ling, Corey, Enright, Kelly; all hard running, strong over the ball, experienced, talented players. Melbourne, on the other hand, are a light, young side not yet used to said plan or physically capable of such a contact-intense style of footy.
Incidentally, just as Geelong struggle to beat Hawthorn's cluster, which clogs up the central running lanes, Melbourne will also struggle to deal with Hawthorn. It's no coincidence that it was the Hawks who spanked Melbourne in round one.
Comments
m0nty
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Big Ramifications
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Tony Tea
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Tony Tea
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Professor Rosseforp
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Tony Tea
ALLPARK FIGURE (6)
Tony Tea
CUT A SHORT STORY LONG (3)
Tony Tea
CUT A SHORT STORY LONG (3)
Professor Rosseforp
CUT A SHORT STORY LONG (3)
Tony Tea