Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Brett Pee

For so much of the 90's our slip cordon resembled a ring of steel, there is an inherent danger of it becoming a ring of pansies.But our future frailties do not lie so much in missed catches/ ageing fielders? etc BUT adequate replacements for Pigeon and Warnie.The system is in place but we must NOT give those bloody Poms a sniff of any future ashes success.Personally, i do not remember an ashes defeat...let's keep it that way.

The Hack

Can't bowl. Can't catch. Can't believe Magilla keeps getting picked.


In my pinion you've hit right on the issue, Brett. It's not the fact the slips might be slipping, it's the fact that there aren't as many chances coming their way. It's much easier to snaffle blinders when there's no pressure implied by the fact that if you miss one, you won't get another chance for ages. That seems the problem to me at the moment.

The number of wickets he gets means he is always going to be next cab off the rank, Hack. Never the less, it's not insignificant that India are the main threat to Aussie superiority. After all, they are the best players of spin. It's not a coincidence we seem to be able to flog everyone else - except the Shrees and home - and yet struggle against India. Still, MacGilla better learn to catch. Warne is a terrific catch, and if anything, it's that ability that will see him back in the side in front of MacGill.


Warne is a very handy batsman as well; MacGill's giving McGrath some stiff competition in the batting stakes.


There's many an expert out there who reckon Warnie should have made many more test runs. He's got a good enough eye and technique when he wants. However, the way he got out on 99 against New Zealand in Perth two years ago is a good indication of why he hasn't. A headstrong tonker.


I dunno that his technique is THAT good. Warnie's batting is more arse then class. Still, he's a better cricketer then MacGill by any measure, and I impatiently await his return.


I'm not saying he's got a GREAT technique, just a better one than his average to date warrants. Still, roll on Warnie's return.

Brett Pee

I think i'm a better bowler than McGill. But i'm 10 k's overweight, drink only ice cold lager, exist on a diet of chips and can't bloody run for Edna. I might ring the selecters....



Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)