With his bold claim that Gimme Shelter is the Best Ever Rock & Roll Song, Tim Dunlop's opened the gate and let the wild horses bolt. Three posts already out there and mine on the way. Although I notice the Pirate Pundit is yet to nail his colours to the mast. Yet.
As it happens I know of three friends who, at one time or another, have sworn black and blue that Gimme Shelter is the best ever Stones song. Two of them, like Tim, have said it's the best ever song. Full stop. One of them's even called Tim. And if I strain my mind back to 1977 when we first got a double cassette of Rolled Gold, I'll swear my brother was of the same opinion. My first love was Midnight Rambler.
Sadly Tim - Dunlop that is - doesn't post a list of other Stones favourites so's we can gauge where he's coming from. After all, if he also raves about Start Me Up, Fool To Cry and Angie then, frankly, there's a credibility issue that needs addressing.
Personally? Well, as far as I'm concerned Gimme Shelter is a striking song. I suspect producer Glyn Johns had a freer hand with it – and You Can't Always Get What You Want - but it seems somehow wrong when pitted against the better stuff on Let It Bleed.
There are at least five better songs on that album. All of which sound more like what the Stones did best. Namely Stones brand rock 'n' roll. So for me it's not Number 1, or even the best song of, like, ever dude. I'll say one thing though, it's got a killer filmclip.
Over at HBD, James is also on board and gives us an excellent list. Good to see Satanic Majesties' Citadel, 2000 Man and 2000 Light Years From Home. However, we're in the same timezone with our sixties psychedelia so them being there is not surprising.
And Chris over at Troppo has also weighed in with suggestion that Exile's Let It Loose is the best Stones song. In actual fact, I agree with that. No debate necessary. It IS - big letter shout - their best song. What's more, it's fantastic late at night when you're with other Stones fans and you've had a few cleansing beakers. Sing along with Tone. Tonelessly. Not forgetting Elvis's American Trilogy. Live, of course. "Hit it boys!"
Anyway, for what it's worth and in no particular order, here are my top twenty Stones songs....
It's All Over Now
Flight 505
It's Not Easy
I Am Waiting
Jumping Jack Flash
2000 Light Years From Home
Child Of The Moon
Street Fighting Man
No Expectations
Dear Doctor
Let It Bleed
Midnight Rambler
Monkey Man
Live With Me
Dead Flowers
Moonlight Mile
Rocks Off
Loving Cup
Sweet Virginia
Let It Loose
Bonus Track: Faraway Eyes - It always makes me laugh.
I've never been a huge rap for Satisfaction or Honky Tonk Women, and as you can see from the list, all the songs bar one fall into Chris's early to middle era. Aftermath, where they invented white-boy blues, the much maligned Satanic Majesties, Beggars, Let It Bleed, Sticky and their pizza with the lot, Exile on Main Street.
Of their non-core era I'd like to have included songs like Silver Train, It's Only Rock & Roll, Melody and Respectable but twenty's a pretty fair sample and they were up against some stiff competition. I've gotta draw the line somewhere.
And I never even started in on the live tracks....
"For the next hour. Is everybody ready? We're sorry for the delay."
Update: This seems like as good a time as any to run a poll. So I've chosen my ten favourite Stones albums and put them over on the left.
By the way, Fame won the last one, but I care less than all of you not put together. They were all crap.
Comments
Sharron
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Professor Rosseforp
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Big Ramifications
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Professor Rosseforp
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Tony Tea
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
os
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Big Rammer's mum
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Big Ramifications
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Tony Tea
UNDERWEAR BADNESS (13)
Big Ramifications